Our Menu

Download Our Menu (PDF File)

Meat Fest Pizza

sm. - $14.30 med. - $18.45 lg. - $21.55

pepperoni, sausage, beef, Canadian Bacon, bacon

Pagliai’s Special

sm - $14.30 med. - $18.45 lg. - $21.55

Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Sausage, Beef, Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions

House Special

sm. - $11.50 med. - $15.25 lg. - $17.85

Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Sausage, Onions, Green Peppers

Joe's Special

sm. - $15.20 med. - $19.55 lg. - $22.90

Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Sausage, Pepperoni, Extra Cheese, Onions, Canadian Bacon, Extra Sauce

Everything Pizza

sm. - $20.40 med. - $25.55 lg. - $29.60

Our 10 item special (Allow 30 Min. Cooking Time)

Big Red – Tomato Pizza

sm. - $15.20 med. - $19.40 lg. - $22.60

Thick Pan with Tomatoes & Triple Cheese (Allow 30 Min. Cooking Time)

Little Red – Tomato Pizza

sm. - $11.50 med. - $15.25 lg. - $17.85

Thin Pan with Tomatoes & Blend of Cheeses. Only Available in Thin Pan.

Signature Pepperoni Pizza

sm. - $11.50 med. - $15.25 lg. - $17.85

Our Original Thin Crust with Pepperoni and Special Blend of Cheeses. Only Available in Thin Pan.

BBQ Chicken Pizza

sm. - $10.10 med. - $13.65 lg. - $16.00

Our Original Thin Crust with BBQ Chicken

Chicken Fajita Pizza

sm. - $11.50 med. - $15.25 lg. - $17.85

Our Original Thin Crust with Chicken & Seasoned Grilled Vegetables

Chicken Ranch Pizza

sm. - $12.90 med. - $16.85 lg. - $19.70

Our Original Thin Crust with Savory Ranch Sauce, Chicken, Tomatoes & Bacon

Vegetarian Special #2

sm. - $13.90 med. - $18.05 lg. - $21.15

Our Original Thin Crust Pizza with Tomato, Spinach, Broccoli, Mushrooms

Create Your Own Pizza

sm. - $10.85 med. - $14.55 lg. - $16.95

Choose your crust (original or whole wheat) and delicious toppings to create your own pizza! Each Additional Ingredient: sm. $1.40, med. $1.60...

Lite & Healthy Pizza

sm. - $8.60 med. - $11.95 lg. - $14.05

Thin Crust. Choice of tomato sauce or olive oil sauce. Lite blend of cheeses and your choice of toppings. Baked crisp on brickovens. A true...

Single Ingredient Thick Pizza

sm. - $10.85 med. - $14.55 lg. - $16.95

Original or Whole Wheat Crust | Available in Thick Crust Crisp or Thick Pan | Each Additional Ingredient: sm. $1.30, med. $1.50, lg. $1.75

Thick Cheese Pizza

sm. - $9.45 med. - $12.95 lg. - $15.10

A classic cheese pizza to satisfy your taste buds! Original or Whole Wheat Crust

Single Ingredient Thin Pizza

sm. - $10.10 med. - $13.65 lg. - $16.00

Original or Whole Wheat Crust | Available in Thin Crust Crisp or Thin Pan | Each Additional Ingredient: sm. $1.30, med. $1.50, lg. $1.75

Cheese Pizza

sm. - $8.70 med. - $12.05 lg. - $14.15

A classic cheese pizza to satisfy your taste buds! Original or Whole Wheat Crust

Pagliai’s Sweet Vinaigrette Salad Dressing

$5.50

Our signature house dressing.

Dinner Salad

$3.50

Dressings: Italian, Ranch, Thousand Island, French, Creamy Italian, Poppy Seed, Blue Cheese, Pagliai’s own Sweet Vinaigrette (Fat Free)...

Italian Chef Salad

$8.40

Pepperoni, Onion, Canadian Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese, Black Olive with House Dressing, with Garlic Bread Dressings: Italian, Ranch, Thousand...

Chicken Wings

Half $6.50 Full $12.75

Available in Hot & Spicy

Garlic Cheese Sticks

12" w/Sauce $10.75 14" w/Sauce $11.75

Includes Marinara Sauce

Bread Sticks

$2.80

(2) Bread Sticks with Sauce

Pizza Bread

$3.60

Extra Toppings…..$1.00

Cheese Bread

$3.35

Toasted bread topped with cheese.

Garlic Bread

$1.99

Toasted bread topped with garlic and butter.

Fettuccini Alfredo Dinner

Half - $10.45 Full - $11.55

All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Fettuccini AlfredoHalf

$7.25 Full - $8.50

All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Cavatelli Dinner

Full - $12.10

Small shell-like noodles with meat sauce, baked with layers of cheese. Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.

Cavatelli

Full - $9.60

Small shell-like noodles with meat sauce, baked with layers of cheese. All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Manicotti Dinner

Full - $12.10

Two large shells stuffed with three cheeses, with meat sauce. Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.

Manicotti

Full - $9.60

Two large shells stuffed with three cheeses, with meat sauce. All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Lasagna Dinner

Full - $12.60

Three layers of noodles, three cheeses, with meat sauce. Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.

Lasagna

Full - $10.10

All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Chicken Alfredo Dinner

Half - $10.75 Full - $12.85

Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.

Chicken Alfredo

Half - $8.85 Full - $10.10

All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Fettuccini Primavera Dinner

Half - $10.55 Full - $11.55

Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.

Fettuccini Primavera

Half - $8.00 Full - $9.45

All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Mostaccioli Dinner

Half - $8.15 Full - $9.45

Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.

Mostaccioli

Half - $6.85 Full - $8.00

Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Spaghetti Dinner

Half - $10.35 Full - $11.45

Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). Dinners include pasta, garlic bread, and salad.

Spaghetti

Half - $6.85 Full - $8.00

Choice of meat sauce or marinara (meatless). All pastas are served with garlic bread.

Italian Beef

$6.99

All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$1.00

Poorboy

$6.95

Ham, Salami, Cheese w/ French Dressing and Lettuce. All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$1.00

Veggie Sandwich

$5.95

Mushroom, Onion, Black Olive, Green Pepper, Cheese | All sandwiches include chips. | Extras…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$1.00

Ham & Cheeese

$6.60

All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$1.00

Meatball Sandwich

$6.95

All sandwiches include chips. | Extra Meat…..$1.99 | Add Cheese…..$1.00

40 degree below Joe

1 for $3.49 2 for $6.00

Chocolate Torte (Gluten Free)

$6.95

A flourless chocolate cake with a chocolate ganache glaze over top.

Italian Cream (Slice)

$6.95

For any special occasion, this layered cake has hints of coconut and nuts with a smooth cream icing.

Titamisu

$6.95

A popular coffee-flavored Italian custard dessert.

Chocolate Lovin Spoonful Cake

$6.95

Chocolate cake with thick layers of chocolate fudge filling.

Classic Cheesecake

$5.95

A crumbly graham cracker crust and silky cream cheese filling.

Turtle Cheesecake

$6.95

Cheesecake with chocolate-caramel drizzle.

Large Salad Bowl

In-House $25.00 To-Go $30.00

Serves 10-15 People. Includes bottle of dressing & silverware plate sets.

Small Salad Bowl

$15.00

Serves 6-8 People

Cavatelli (10″ x 13″ Pan)

$57.75

Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People

Manicotti (10″ x 13″ Pan)

$57.75

Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People

Lasagna (10″ x 13″ Pan)

$57.75

Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People

Chicken Alfredo (10″ x 13″ Pan)

$57.75

Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People

Fettuccini (10″ x 13″ Pan)

$52.50

Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People

Mostaccioli (10″ x 13″ Pan)

$52.50

Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People

Spaghetti (10″ x 13″ Pan)

$52.50

Includes Garlic Bread | Serves 8-10 People

Sweet Tea

$1.85

Sprite

Small $1.95 Large (Free Refills) $2.25 Pitchers $5.95 2-Liter $2.99

Pibb Extra

$1.95

Milk

$1.85

Mello Yellow

$1.95

Lemonade

$1.95

Iced Tea

$1.85

Fanta Orange

20 oz. Bottle $1.89 2-Liter $2.99

Diet Coke

Small $1.95 Large (Free Refills) $2.25 Pitchers $5.95 2-Liter $2.99

Decaf Coffee

$2.95

Coke Zero

Small Fountain $1.95 20 oz. Bottle $1.89

Coke

Small $1.95 Large (Free Refills) $2.25 Pitchers $5.95 2-Liter $2.99

Coffee

$2.95

Tomato

Spinach

Shrimp

Sausage

Pinapple

Pepperone

Pepperoncinis

Onion

Olive Oil Sauce

Jalapenos

Ham

Green Peppers

Green Olives

Garlic

Fresh Mushrooms

Extra Souce

Extra Cheese

Chicken

Chicken

Cheese (Ground Fresh)

Canadian Bacon

Broccoli

Black Olives

Beef

Barbeque Sauce

Banana Peppers

Bacon

Anchovie

Alfredo Sauce